Bug 4632

Be carefull this is rpmsrate-raw. It is explanded then on final repository in media/media_info/rpmsrate. So we don't have to list all of them, only 2.

ok, but http://distrib-coffee.ipsl.jussieu.fr/pub/linux/Mageia/distrib/1/x86_64/media/media_info/rpmsrate is the one used no ? (cf url)

Oups sorry read this too fast. Indeed,it was not expanded properly

Thierry or Pascal can you have a look there? looks like mkcd stroke again

CC: (none) => pterjan

well
CAT_SPELLCHECK
 5 hunspell-bg hunspell-ca 129 4 voikko-fi

got expanded into:
CAT_SPELLCHECK
  5 myspell-af_ZA myspell-am_AM (...)
  4 aspell-af aspell-am aspell-az (...)
  4 voikko-fi

Guess it's considering the provides when expanding
For you Pascal...

Source RPM: meta-task => mgatools

BTW I can't reproduce locally with mgatools
What's running on the server that is expanding? mdv? mga1?

mga1

Created attachment 1762 [details]
I think this is because hunspell-XX doesn't require locale-XX

Note that this should NOT be applied.
hunspell-XX should be fixed instead

Kamil, can you add the proper Requires:locales-XX to hunspell-XX ?
Should be pretty automatisable with perl

Created attachment 1764 [details]
perl example how to bump mkrel & add needed requires

(In reply to comment #9)
> Kamil, can you add the proper Requires:locales-XX to hunspell-XX ?
> Should be pretty automatisable with perl

Is this really the only way? I was looking previously into distros, and dictionaries don't need locales.... how about users who just want use dictionaries in different languages? Are they forced to install extra unneeded locales?

Also there are many languages without locales...

(In reply to comment #9)
> Kamil, can you add the proper Requires:locales-XX to hunspell-XX ?
> Should be pretty automatisable with perl

We are using univeral providing for Hunspell (and I have to check the Finnish voikko) dictionary-XX. Can we make a use of it?

Well, we don't care how other distro do it :-)
This is how we always worked (for more than a decade).
Eg: aspell-XX requires the proper locales-XX package
Same for firefox-XX

As for "dictionaries don't need locales", this is not true, things like word breaking can depend on locale definition (what compound letters should remains as a block, what is word break, ...).
see glibc-i18ndata

Last but not least, _NO_ other distro have locales-XX :-) (modulo mdv of course)
So distro comparison is offtopic

So please add those requires.

(In reply to comment #14 and #15)
Ah. OK, I will do it tonight

Status: NEW => ASSIGNED

Thx

(In reply to comment #16)
> Thx

Hi! Excuse me, I'm practicing my Perl programming and I'm writing a script in Perl to do it globally and under control. And now for a while I'm on a small trip, so it's slower.

(In reply to comment #9)
> Kamil, can you add the proper Requires:locales-XX to hunspell-XX ?

hunspell-so-0.1.5-4.mga2
hspell-1.2-2.mga2
hunspell-zu-0.20100126.1-6.mga2
hunspell-yi-1.1-5.mga2
hunspell-xh-0.20091030.1-5.mga2
hunspell-wa-0.4.15-7.mga2
hunspell-vi-0.20080604.1-7.mga2
hunspell-ve-0.20091030.1-5.mga2
hunspell-uz-0.6-7.mga2
hunspell-ur-0.64-6.mga2
hunspell-uk-1.6.0-5.mga2
hunspell-ts-0.20091101.1-5.mga2
hunspell-tn-0.20091101.1-5.mga2
hunspell-tl-0.20050109.1-8.mga2
hunspell-tk-0.01-4.mga2
hunspell-th-0.20061212.1-9.mga2
hunspell-te-0.20050929.1-8.mga2
hunspell-ta-20100226-5.mga2
hunspell-sw-0.20050819.1-8.mga2
hunspell-sv-1.44-5.mga2
hunspell-st-0.20091030.1-5.mga2
hunspell-ss-0.20091030.1-5.mga2
hunspell-sr-0.20100920.1-6.mga2
hunspell-sq-1.6.2-4.mga2
hunspell-sl-0.20070127.1-9.mga2
hunspell-sk-0.20091213.1-6.mga2
hunspell-si-0.2.1-6.mga2
hunspell-shs-0.20090828.1-5.mga2
hunspell-se-1.0-0.3.beta7.3.mga2
hunspell-sc-0.20081101.1-7.mga2
hunspell-rw-0.20050109.1-7.mga2
hunspell-ru-0.99f7-8.mga2
hunspell-ro-3.3.6-5.mga2
hunspell-pt-0.20111025.1-5.mga2
hunspell-pl-0.20110708.1-5.mga2
hunspell-pa-20050726-8.mga2
hunspell-or-20050726-8.mga2
hunspell-oc-0.5-7.mga2
hunspell-nso-0.20091201.1-5.mga2
hunspell-nr-0.20091030.1-5.mga2
hunspell-nl-2.00-6.mga2
hunspell-ne-20080425-5.mga2
hunspell-nds-0.1-7.mga2
hunspell-mt-0.20020708.1-7.mga2
hunspell-ms-0.20050117.1-8.mga2
hunspell-mr-20060920-10.mga2
hunspell-mn-0.20080709.1-6.mga2
hunspell-ml-0.1-7.mga2
hunspell-mk-0.20051126.1-6.mga2
hunspell-mi-0.20080630.1-7.mga2
hunspell-mg-0.20050109.1-8.mga2
hunspell-mai-1.0.1-4.mga2
hunspell-lv-0.9.4-7.mga2
hunspell-lt-1.2.1-9.mga2
hunspell-lb-0.20110513.1-5.mga2
hunspell-ky-0.20090415.1-6.mga2
hunspell-ku-0.21-10.mga2
hunspell-ko-0.5.3-4.mga2
hunspell-kn-1.0.3-5.mga2
hunspell-km-1.1-6.mga2
hunspell-kk-1.1-5.mga2
hunspell-it-2.4-0.6.20070901.4.mga2
hunspell-is-0.20090823.1-5.mga2
hunspell-id-0.20040812.1-8.mga2
hunspell-hy-0.20.0-5.mga2
hunspell-hu-1.6.1-5.mga2
hunspell-ht-0.06-4.mga2
hunspell-hsb-0.20060327.3-3.mga2
hunspell-hr-0.20040608.1-11.mga2
hunspell-hi-20050726-10.mga2
hunspell-gv-0.20040505.1-7.mga2
hunspell-gu-20061015-6.mga2
hunspell-gl-0.20080515.1-7.mga2
hunspell-gd-2.1-3.mga2
hunspell-ga-4.6-4.mga2
hunspell-fy-2.0.1-5.mga2
hunspell-fur-0.20050912.1-8.mga2
hunspell-fr-4.2-5.mga2
hunspell-fo-0.4.0-4.mga2
hunspell-fa-0.20070116.1-8.mga2
hunspell-eu-0.20080507.1-7.mga2
hunspell-et-0.20030606.1-11.mga2
hunspell-es-0.20081215.1-7.mga2
hunspell-eo-1.0-0.3.dev.5.mga2
hunspell-en-0.20110318.1-5.mga2
hunspell-el-0.8-6.mga2
hunspell-de-0.20110609.1-5.mga2
hunspell-da-1.7.37-4.mga2
hunspell-cy-0.20040425.1-9.mga2
hunspell-cv-1.02-4.mga2
hunspell-csb-0.20050311.1-9.mga2
hunspell-cs-20060303-15.mga2
hunspell-ca-2.2.0-6.mga2
hunspell-br-0.8-4.mga2
hunspell-bn-0.04-5.mga2
hunspell-bg-4.3-5.mga2
hunspell-ber-0.20080210.1-6.mga2
hunspell-be-1.1-6.mga2
hunspell-az-0.20040827.1-9.mga2
hunspell-ast-0.02-2.mga2
hunspell-as-1.0.3-7.mga2
hunspell-ar-0.20080110.1-9.mga2
hunspell-am-0.20090704.1-8.mga2
hunspell-af-0.20080825.1-8.mga2

104 packages are updated.
The last one seems to be -nb, we shall consider to obsolete locales-no with locales-nb.

What about mythes-*, hyphen-* and autocorr-*?

> Should be pretty automatisable with perl
It took me 1 full day to do it with Perl.

No need to obsolete it, locales-no provides it (it was renamed)

(In reply to comment #19)
> No need to obsolete it, locales-no provides it (it was renamed)

OK. I have added the requirement on locales-no for hunspell-nn and hunspell-nb.

So everything is done with hunspell.

Now it's time for mythes-*, hyphen-* and autocorr-*.

I will do the same for these packages.

(In reply to comment #8)
> Created attachment 1762 [details]
> I think this is because hunspell-XX doesn't require locale-XX
> 
> Note that this should NOT be applied.
> hunspell-XX should be fixed instead

Tell me please if it's now working.

> (In reply to comment #19)
Note it's not urgent since those are not in rpmsrate and are only required by
packages (libreoffice-langpack-XX) that also requires locales-XX(In reply to comment #20)

> (In reply to comment #20)
Yes. Just look at media/media_info/rpmsrate on your favorite mirror

> > (In reply to comment #19)
> Note it's not urgent since those are not in rpmsrate and are only required by
> packages (libreoffice-langpack-XX) that also requires locales-XX(In reply to
> comment #20)
OK! So I won't apply changes. I am planning to clean these packages for mga3 (importing possibly missing ones, etc).

> 
> > (In reply to comment #20)
> Yes. Just look at media/media_info/rpmsrate on your favorite mirror

Wow, nice.
Feel free to close this bug as resolved if everything is fine.

Closing

Status: ASSIGNED => RESOLVED
Resolution: (none) => FIXED

thanks all \o/