Bug 21739

Antony Baker spotted this:
https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension_talk:Moderation#Existing_users_moderated.3F

Existing users aren't added to the automoderated group, so every user will have to go through moderation.

It would be nice if all _existing_ users https://wiki.mageia.org/en/Special:ListUsers are added to the automoderated group when we start using this extension... afaik none of them has been vandalizing.

(In reply to Marja van Waes from comment #1)
> Antony Baker spotted this:
> https://www.mediawiki.org/wiki/Extension_talk:
> Moderation#Existing_users_moderated.3F
> 
> Existing users aren't added to the automoderated group, so every user will
> have to go through moderation.
> 
> It would be nice if all _existing_ users
> https://wiki.mageia.org/en/Special:ListUsers are added to the automoderated
> group when we start using this extension... afaik none of them has been
> vandalizing.

Apart from those who are blocked, of course ;-)

Ideally only those who have actually posted to the wiki, and not been blocked
already.

CC: (none) => davidwhodgins

(In reply to Dave Hodgins from comment #3)
> Ideally only those who have actually posted to the wiki, and not been blocked
> already.

You're right, thanks

That would be this list, except the 142 blocked users in it
https://wiki.mageia.org/mw-en/index.php?title=Special:ListUsers&offset=&limit=1000&username=&group=&editsOnly=1

Well, both would be OK in my opinion (that would still block spammers who usually create accounts just before spamming, and we can revert any spam done by an 'old' user), so I'll do whatever I manage to do :)

My concern is that the spammers may have already bulk created identities, so
just has to get around to using them, rather then create new ones.

(In reply to Dave Hodgins from comment #6)
> My concern is that the spammers may have already bulk created identities, so
> just has to get around to using them, rather then create new ones.

Around the times that used spam accounts were created, other user accounts were created, too, that haven't been used 
https://wiki.mageia.org/mw-en/index.php?title=Special:ListUsers&offset=&limit=2000&username=&group=&creationSort=1&desc=1

(or we forgot to block them when deleting their pages)... of course the examples given below may be of good willing real users, but we don't know for sure.
e.g.: 
Kattupa12
Rohan12
Somi1
Onlineakv

Well, in the worst case, they spam, we revert, we block them, and they're out.

If I can easily do what you said, I will, otherwise that will apply only to new users.

Or maybe I could make everyone moderated and let moderators unblock manually those who contributed in the last year.

Samuel

(In reply to Samuel Verschelde from comment #8)
> Well, in the worst case, they spam, we revert, we block them, and they're
> out.
> 
> If I can easily do what you said, I will, otherwise that will apply only to
> new users.

No problem

> 
> Or maybe I could make everyone moderated and let moderators unblock manually
> those who contributed in the last year.
> 

I think the last option needs feedback from the docteam leaders... I don't think that's what anyone had in mind when we chose to start moderating.

CC: (none) => lebarhon, yves.brungard_mageia

I think that we can add the list of users who already edited a page in the wiki, minus who are blocked, in the whitelist.
https://wiki.mageia.org/mw-en/index.php?title=Special:ListUsers&offset=&limit=1000&username=&group=&editsOnly=1

Created attachment 9680 [details]
users who edited in the past and aren't blocked

(In reply to papoteur from comment #10)
> I think that we can add the list of users who already edited a page in the
> wiki, minus who are blocked, in the whitelist.
> https://wiki.mageia.org/mw-en/index.php?title=Special:
> ListUsers&offset=&limit=1000&username=&group=&editsOnly=1


Not sure the title whitelist is meant for that, another option would be to put them in a new group of trusted users.

Anyway, in case that helps, attaching my list of users who have done edits in the past and aren't blocked.

(In reply to Marja van Waes from comment #11)
> attaching my list of users who have done edits
> in the past and aren't blocked.

The past being: until I uploaded that list ;-)

I'll leave this report open, even if we've worked around the issue by letting new users request edit rights, because I think using the Moderation extension would still be better.