| Summary: | mga5.1 Classic iso install of KDE4 fails at login | ||
|---|---|---|---|
| Product: | Mageia | Reporter: | Len Lawrence <tarazed25> |
| Component: | Release (media or process) | Assignee: | KDE maintainers <kde> |
| Status: | RESOLVED OLD | QA Contact: | |
| Severity: | major | ||
| Priority: | High | CC: | marja11, sysadmin-bugs, tmb |
| Version: | 5 | Keywords: | 5.1 |
| Target Milestone: | --- | ||
| Hardware: | x86_64 | ||
| OS: | Linux | ||
| Whiteboard: | |||
| Source RPM: | CVE: | ||
| Status comment: | |||
| Attachments: | journalctl -b output for mga5.1 test iso | ||
|
Description
Len Lawrence
2016-11-09 01:14:59 CET
Just tried out my theory that KDE was trying to use the Intel graphics as well. Connected a 3K monitor to the DVI output, which resulted in two similar Mate desktop displays. Rebooted and chose KDE at login and saw the KDE desktop established on both screens. Could not say which was master.
Could this problem be something to do with the way the system configures X? Two heads and all that. The user receives no feedback on this at install time.
Whatever is happening does not seem to be reflected in xorg.conf:
Section "Device"
Identifier "device1"
VendorName "NVIDIA Corporation"
BoardName "NVIDIA GeForce 420 series and later"
Driver "nvidia"
Option "DPMS"
Option "DynamicTwinView" "false"
Option "AddARGBGLXVisuals"
EndSection
Section "Screen"
Identifier "screen1"
Device "device1"
Monitor "monitor1"
EndSection
Tried running drakx11 to ensure that display mode was not forced to DVI but that did not help. That was a long shot because the real puzzle is what is the difference between the desktops as far as DP and DVI are concerned? Why or how does KDE require both when Mate is happy to use DP only? And KDE heretofore worked fine with DP. Created attachment 8642 [details]
journalctl -b output for mga5.1 test iso
Samuel Verschelde
2016-11-09 10:31:13 CET
Keywords:
(none) =>
5.1 Have just performed a GNOME only installation of mga5.1 and logged in without any problem. Copied the mga5.1 classic iso to another USB key and installed KDE again, KDE only. Ensured that the latest updates were applied before reboot and tried again. Just the same, disconnected monitor. (In reply to Len Lawrence from comment #0) > As far as the tests have gone, this occurs on one machine only and it is > consistent. MSI motherboard, nvidia GTX970 graphics. The monitor is a Dell > 4K display connected to the nvidia card on the DisplayPort. A DVI output is > available but I suspect that it connects to the onboard Intel graphics. If the dvi port is on the graphic card, it's connected to the GTX... Can you try to confirm (or not) if it's a displayport issue. CC:
(none) =>
tmb I checked all this out a year ago. The DVI output is not on the graphics card. I had been experimenting with a 3K monitor and found that there was no nvidia graphics with DVI which proved there was no connection to the graphics card. I was puzzled by the lack of DVI input ports on the monitor and later discovered that DVI does not have the bandwidth to support anything larger than 3K. Another KDE install on an old nvidia laptop has just booted and passed the login stage OK. So I think that this shows that this is a Display Port issue, but only for KDE. And as noted earlier, KDE and Plasma have run without issues on this hardware over the past year or so. My experiment with the two monitors seems to show that KDE expects to find a DVI connected display before it can continue. When it finds one, the DP monitor echoes the desktop. Something has definitely changed in KDE. (In reply to Len Lawrence from comment #7) > > Another KDE install on an old nvidia laptop has just booted and passed the > login stage OK. > > So I think that this shows that this is a Display Port issue, but only for > KDE. And as noted earlier, KDE and Plasma have run without issues on this > hardware over the past year or so. My experiment with the two monitors > seems to show that KDE expects to find a DVI connected display before it can > continue. When it finds one, the DP monitor echoes the desktop. > > Something has definitely changed in KDE. Assigning to KDE team, then. @ tmb, neoclust and all Please correct me if that's the wrong assignee CC:
(none) =>
marja11 Yes, thanks Marja. It certainly looks like KDE and an edge case at that. Apologies. This bug does not appear to be consistent. Dumping the ISO to another USB key gives a bootable Live KDE4 using the DP panel. Sorry for the noise. First rule; if a USB pendrive gives trouble try another one. :( Status:
NEW =>
UNCONFIRMED Scratch that. Totally confused here. It was not a Live iso that gave the trouble. Going to try a copy of the Classic iso again. Yes, the problem persists with another drive. The experiment with the two monitors indicated that there really was a problem. Status:
UNCONFIRMED =>
NEW Tried another approach; custom install with GNOME, KDE4 and Mate. KDE login failed as before, Mate succeeded. Closing as OLD, because this bug cannot exist in newer isos than Mga 5.1, since KDM & KDE were replaced with SDDM & Plasma5 Status:
NEW =>
RESOLVED |