Bug 1114

Summary: Remaining Mandriva RPMs after URPMI upgrade to mageia beta 2 from 2010.2 (May 2nd)
Product: Mageia Reporter: Matthieu Nguyen <nguyen.matthieu>
Component: InstallerAssignee: Mageia Bug Squad <bugsquad>
Status: RESOLVED OLD QA Contact:
Severity: normal    
Priority: Normal CC: balcaen.john, cazzaniga.sandro
Version: Cauldron   
Target Milestone: ---   
Hardware: i586   
OS: Linux   
Whiteboard:
Source RPM: CVE:
Status comment:

Description Matthieu Nguyen 2011-05-03 13:00:10 CEST
Description of problem:

After upgrading my old desktop from Mandriva 2010.2 to Mageia Cauldron 1 Beta 2, and following the documented "upgrade testing procedure" on the wiki, for an urpmi upgrade, I obtained a list of 160+ leftover packages that were still named mdv. The wiki page asks to report a bug for all the mdv leftovers, so here goes :)

Version-Release number of selected component (if applicable): Mageia Cauldron 1 Beta 2, i586

How reproducible:
Always

Steps to Reproduce:
1. Install Mageia 1 Cauldron Beta 2 using the urpmi update method
2. rpm -qa | grep mdv

Here is the list I obtained.

apache-mod_suexec-2.2.15-1mdv2010.1
codeina-0.10.7-1mdv2010.1
drakbackup-0.19.3-1mdv2010.1
drakfirsttime-2.25.5-1mdv2010.1
drakmenustyle-0.14.1-3mdv2010.1
dynamic-0.26.17-4mdv2010.1
eel-2.26.0-2mdv2010.0
emacs-php-mode-1.5.0-1mdv2009.1
gdk-pixbuf-loaders-0.22.0-16mdv2010.1
gimp2-pandora-0.9.2-3mdv2010.0
gimp-help-2-common-2.4.2-2mdv2010.0
gnome-mount-0.8-7mdv2010.1
gnome-spell-1.0.8-3mdv2009.0
gnome-themes-extras-2.22.0-5mdv2010.1
gstreamer0.10-decoders-1-5mdv2010.1
gstreamer0.10-decoders-audio-1-5mdv2010.1
gtkdialogs-2.2-6mdv2010.1
hardware-monitor-1.4.2-1mdv2010.0
hcl-1.7.1-3mdv2010.1
htdig-3.2.0-4mdv2010.1
hwdb-clients-0.18-5mdv2010.1
libadns1-1.4-6mdv2010.1
libapr_memcache0-0.7.0-14mdv2009.0
libarts1-1.5.10-8mdv2009.1
libavahi-core5-0.6.23-1.2mdv2009.0
libavahi-core6-0.6.25-5.2mdv2010.2
libavahi-qt3_1-0.6.25-5.2mdv2010.2
libbeagle1-0.3.9-3mdv2010.1
libboost1.36.0-1.36.0-1mdv2009.0
libboost_filesystem1.42.0-1.42.0-3.2mdv2010.1
libboost_python1.42.0-1.42.0-3.2mdv2010.1
libboost_system1.42.0-1.42.0-3.2mdv2010.1
libboost_thread1.42.0-1.42.0-3.2mdv2010.1
libbrasero0-2.30.2-1mdv2010.1
libbreakpad0-2.30.0-1mdv2010.1
libcamel14-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libcap1-1.10-10mdv2009.0
libcdio10-0.81-5mdv2010.0
libcdio7-0.80-2mdv2009.0
libcelt0_0-0.7.1-1mdv2010.1
libcfitsio3-3.240-1mdv2010.1
libcgraph4-2.24.0-1.3mdv2010.0
libcryptopp6-5.5.2-3mdv2009.1
libdatrie0-0.1.3-2mdv2009.1
libdb4.2-4.2.52-29mdv2010.1
libdb4.6-4.6.21-25mdv2010.1
libdbi0-0.8.3-4mdv2010.1
libdbnss4.6-4.6.21-25mdv2010.1
libdbus-qt-1_1-0.70-6mdv2010.1
libdirectfb1.2_0-1.2.8-4mdv2010.0
libdirectfb1.4_0-1.4.3-2mdv2010.1
libdvbpsi5-0.1.6-4mdv2010.0
libebml0-0.7.8-3mdv2010.0
libebook9-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libecal7-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libedata-book2-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libedata-cal6-2.28.2-1.1mdv2010.0
libedata-cal7-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libedataserver11-2.28.2-1.1mdv2010.0
libedataserver13-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libedataserverui8-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libeel2_2-2.26.0-2mdv2010.0
libepc1.0_1-0.3.5-1mdv2009.0
libevent2-1.4.13-2mdv2010.1
libevince0-2.24.0-2.1mdv2009.0
libevince2-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.2
libexchange-storage3-2.28.2-1.1mdv2010.0
libexiv2_6-0.19-1mdv2010.1
libgdata1-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libgdk-pixbuf2-0.22.0-16mdv2010.1
libglib1.2-1.2.10-24mdv2010.0
libgluezilla0-2.6-2mdv2010.1
libgmime2.0_2-2.2.26-1mdv2010.1
libgmp3-4.3.1-1mdv2010.0
libgnome-desktop-2_11-2.28.1-1.1mdv2010.0
libgpm1-1.20.1-22mdv2009.0
libgs8-8.71-71.2mdv2010.1
libgsmlib1-1.11-5.7mdv2010.1
libgtk+1.2-1.2.10-51mdv2010.1
libgtk-linux-fb-2.0_0-2.4.14-11mdv2010.1
libicu40-4.0.1-1mdv2009.1
libiso9660_5-0.80-2mdv2009.0
libjbig0-1.6-3mdv2009.0
libjpeg7-7-5mdv2010.0
liblazy1-0.2-4mdv2010.1
libldap2.3_0-2.3.43-1mdv2009.0
libldetect0.7-0.7.27-2mdv2009.1
liblm_sensors3-2.10.8-1mdv2009.1
libltdl3-1.5.26-6mdv2009.1
liblzma0-4.999.3-0.alpha.3mdv2009.0
liblzma2-4.999.9beta-2mdv2010.1
libmagick3-6.6.1.5-2mdv2010.1
libmatroska0-0.8.1-2mdv2010.0
libmediadevicelib1-2.1.1-0.7mdv2009.1
libmlt2-0.5.10-1mdv2010.1
libmodplug0-0.8.7-2mdv2010.1
libmodprobe1-3.5-2.1mdv2009.0
libmp4v2_0-2.0-0.20090110.1mdv2009.1
libmpfr1-2.4.2-2mdv2010.1
libmutter-private0-2.29.1-4mdv2010.1
libmysql15-5.0.67-3mdv2009.0
libmysql16-5.1.55-0.1mdv2010.2
libnautilus-burn4-2.24.0-1mdv2009.0
libneon0.26-0.26.4-8mdv2010.0
libnice0-0.0.11-1mdv2010.1
libnm_util0-0.7.0-3mdv2009.0
libopenssl0.9.8-0.9.8n-1mdv2010.1
libpcap0-0.9.8-3mdv2009.0
libpolkit-gnome0-0.9.2-5mdv2010.1
libpoppler5-0.12.4-2.1mdv2010.1
libpoppler-glib4-0.12.4-2.1mdv2010.1
libpoppler-qt2-0.12.4-2.1mdv2010.1
libportaudio0-18.1-12mdv2010.1
libpq8.3_5-8.3.11-3mdv2010.1
libproxy0-0.3.1-2mdv2010.1
libpython2.5-2.5.2-5.2mdv2009.0
libpython2.6-2.6.5-2.2mdv2010.1
libqassistantclient1-3.3.8b-18mdv2010.1
librasqal1-0.9.16-3mdv2010.0
libreadline5-5.2-11mdv2009.1
libresmgr1-1.0-13mdv2010.0
librhythmbox0-0.12.8-1mdv2010.1
libSDL_gfx0-2.0.18-2mdv2010.0
libsgutils1-1.25-1mdv2009.0
libsox0-14.1.0-1mdv2009.0
libstdc++5-3.3.6-4mdv2009.0
libswfdec0.8_0-0.8.4-2mdv2010.1
libtcl8.5-8.5.4-1mdv2009.0
libtk8.5-8.5.4-1mdv2009.0
libtorrent-rasterbar5-0.14.10-3mdv2010.1
libuClibc0.9.30.1-0.9.30.1-12mdv2010.1
libvisual-plugins-0.4.0-11mdv2010.1
libwpg-0.1_1-0.1.3-3mdv2010.1
libwps0.1_1-0.1.2-4mdv2010.1
libxaw6-1.0.4-5mdv2009.0
libxaw8-1.0.4-5mdv2009.1
libxmlsec1-1-1.2.14-3mdv2010.1
libxmlsec1-nss1-1.2.14-3mdv2010.1
libxrdp0-0.4.1-4mdv2010.1
libxulrunner1.9.2.13-1.9.2.13-0.2mdv2010.2
libxulrunner1.9.2.16-1.9.2.16-0.1mdv2010.2
libxulrunner1.9.2.17-1.9.2.17-0.1mdv2010.2
mandriva-doc-common-2010.1-1.0mdv2010.1
mandriva-theme-Free-screensaver-1.4.7-2mdv2010.1
mdkonline-2.77.21-1.2mdv2010.1
mdv-distrib-tools-4.02-6.mga1
mdv-rpm-summary-0.9.4-1mdv2010.1
mplayerplugin-3.55-5mdv2010.0
nvidia96xx-kernel-2.6.33.7-desktop-2mnb-96.43.16-2mdv2010.1
nvidia96xx-kernel-desktop-latest-96.43.16-1.20100921.2mdv2010.1
openldap2.3-2.3.43-1mdv2009.0
pidgin-guifications-2.16-7mdv2010.0
policykit-gnome-0.9.2-5mdv2010.1
postgresql8.3-8.3.11-3mdv2010.1
python-numeric-24.2-6mdv2010.0
skype-2.0.0.72-mdv
teg-0.11.2-6mdv2010.0
tightvnc-1.3.10-3mdv2010.1
x11-driver-input-citron-2.2.2-1mdv2010.0
x11-font-adobe-utopia-100dpi-1.0.2-1mdv2010.1
x11-font-adobe-utopia-75dpi-1.0.2-1mdv2010.1
x11-font-adobe-utopia-type1-1.0.2-1mdv2010.1

Note: My system has never been scratched since Mdv 2009.0, it has been updated from 2009.0 to 2009.1, to 2010.0 and then to 2010.2, always using the urpmi upgrade method. It is likely that some packages listed above have even been discontinued from Mdv before the MGA fork.
Also, skype has been manually installed from an external repo, no need to take it into account.

Also, I submitted the bug on Installation since I tested an upgrade. Feel free to move it to RPM if it is more appropriate. And thanks again for all the hard work you're doing!
Comment 1 John Balcaen 2011-05-03 13:40:46 CEST
Most of thoses libs should be removed by urpme --auto-orphans.
Could you check the remaining list after using urpme --auto-orphans (before applying check that urpme is not removing some important packages) ?

CC: (none) => balcaen.john

Comment 2 Matthieu Nguyen 2011-05-03 14:39:15 CEST
Here's the remaining list after urpme --auto-orphans



apache-mod_suexec-2.2.15-1mdv2010.1
codeina-0.10.7-1mdv2010.1
drakbackup-0.19.3-1mdv2010.1
drakfirsttime-2.25.5-1mdv2010.1
drakmenustyle-0.14.1-3mdv2010.1
dynamic-0.26.17-4mdv2010.1
eel-2.26.0-2mdv2010.0
emacs-php-mode-1.5.0-1mdv2009.1
gdk-pixbuf-loaders-0.22.0-16mdv2010.1
gimp2-pandora-0.9.2-3mdv2010.0
gimp-help-2-common-2.4.2-2mdv2010.0
gnome-mount-0.8-7mdv2010.1
gnome-spell-1.0.8-3mdv2009.0
gnome-themes-extras-2.22.0-5mdv2010.1
gstreamer0.10-decoders-1-5mdv2010.1
gstreamer0.10-decoders-audio-1-5mdv2010.1
gtkdialogs-2.2-6mdv2010.1
hardware-monitor-1.4.2-1mdv2010.0
hcl-1.7.1-3mdv2010.1
htdig-3.2.0-4mdv2010.1
hwdb-clients-0.18-5mdv2010.1
libapr_memcache0-0.7.0-14mdv2009.0
libarts1-1.5.10-8mdv2009.1
libavahi-core5-0.6.23-1.2mdv2009.0
libavahi-qt3_1-0.6.25-5.2mdv2010.2
libbeagle1-0.3.9-3mdv2010.1
libboost1.36.0-1.36.0-1mdv2009.0
libbreakpad0-2.30.0-1mdv2010.1
libcamel14-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libcap1-1.10-10mdv2009.0
libcdio10-0.81-5mdv2010.0
libcdio7-0.80-2mdv2009.0
libcgraph4-2.24.0-1.3mdv2010.0
libcryptopp6-5.5.2-3mdv2009.1
libdatrie0-0.1.3-2mdv2009.1
libdb4.2-4.2.52-29mdv2010.1
libdb4.6-4.6.21-25mdv2010.1
libdbnss4.6-4.6.21-25mdv2010.1
libdbus-qt-1_1-0.70-6mdv2010.1
libdvbpsi5-0.1.6-4mdv2010.0
libebml0-0.7.8-3mdv2010.0
libebook9-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libecal7-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libedata-book2-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libedata-cal6-2.28.2-1.1mdv2010.0
libedataserver11-2.28.2-1.1mdv2010.0
libedataserver13-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libedataserverui8-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libeel2_2-2.26.0-2mdv2010.0
libepc1.0_1-0.3.5-1mdv2009.0
libevent2-1.4.13-2mdv2010.1
libevince0-2.24.0-2.1mdv2009.0
libexchange-storage3-2.28.2-1.1mdv2010.0
libgdata1-2.30.3-1.1mdv2010.1
libgdk-pixbuf2-0.22.0-16mdv2010.1
libglib1.2-1.2.10-24mdv2010.0
libgluezilla0-2.6-2mdv2010.1
libgmime2.0_2-2.2.26-1mdv2010.1
libgmp3-4.3.1-1mdv2010.0
libgnome-desktop-2_11-2.28.1-1.1mdv2010.0
libgpm1-1.20.1-22mdv2009.0
libgs8-8.71-71.2mdv2010.1
libgsmlib1-1.11-5.7mdv2010.1
libgtk+1.2-1.2.10-51mdv2010.1
libgtk-linux-fb-2.0_0-2.4.14-11mdv2010.1
libicu40-4.0.1-1mdv2009.1
libiso9660_5-0.80-2mdv2009.0
libjbig0-1.6-3mdv2009.0
liblazy1-0.2-4mdv2010.1
libldap2.3_0-2.3.43-1mdv2009.0
libldetect0.7-0.7.27-2mdv2009.1
liblm_sensors3-2.10.8-1mdv2009.1
libltdl3-1.5.26-6mdv2009.1
liblzma0-4.999.3-0.alpha.3mdv2009.0
libmatroska0-0.8.1-2mdv2010.0
libmediadevicelib1-2.1.1-0.7mdv2009.1
libmodplug0-0.8.7-2mdv2010.1
libmodprobe1-3.5-2.1mdv2009.0
libmp4v2_0-2.0-0.20090110.1mdv2009.1
libmpfr1-2.4.2-2mdv2010.1
libmutter-private0-2.29.1-4mdv2010.1
libmysql15-5.0.67-3mdv2009.0
libnautilus-burn4-2.24.0-1mdv2009.0
libneon0.26-0.26.4-8mdv2010.0
libnm_util0-0.7.0-3mdv2009.0
libopenssl0.9.8-0.9.8n-1mdv2010.1
libpcap0-0.9.8-3mdv2009.0
libpolkit-gnome0-0.9.2-5mdv2010.1
libpoppler5-0.12.4-2.1mdv2010.1
libpoppler-qt2-0.12.4-2.1mdv2010.1
libportaudio0-18.1-12mdv2010.1
libpq8.3_5-8.3.11-3mdv2010.1
libpython2.5-2.5.2-5.2mdv2009.0
libpython2.6-2.6.5-2.2mdv2010.1
libqassistantclient1-3.3.8b-18mdv2010.1
libreadline5-5.2-11mdv2009.1
libresmgr1-1.0-13mdv2010.0
librhythmbox0-0.12.8-1mdv2010.1
libSDL_gfx0-2.0.18-2mdv2010.0
libsgutils1-1.25-1mdv2009.0
libsox0-14.1.0-1mdv2009.0
libstdc++5-3.3.6-4mdv2009.0
libswfdec0.8_0-0.8.4-2mdv2010.1
libtcl8.5-8.5.4-1mdv2009.0
libtk8.5-8.5.4-1mdv2009.0
libvisual-plugins-0.4.0-11mdv2010.1
libwpg-0.1_1-0.1.3-3mdv2010.1
libwps0.1_1-0.1.2-4mdv2010.1
libxaw6-1.0.4-5mdv2009.0
libxaw8-1.0.4-5mdv2009.1
libxmlsec1-1-1.2.14-3mdv2010.1
libxmlsec1-nss1-1.2.14-3mdv2010.1
libxrdp0-0.4.1-4mdv2010.1
libxulrunner1.9.2.13-1.9.2.13-0.2mdv2010.2
libxulrunner1.9.2.16-1.9.2.16-0.1mdv2010.2
libxulrunner1.9.2.17-1.9.2.17-0.1mdv2010.2
mandriva-doc-common-2010.1-1.0mdv2010.1
mandriva-theme-Free-screensaver-1.4.7-2mdv2010.1
mdkonline-2.77.21-1.2mdv2010.1
mdv-distrib-tools-4.02-6.mga1
mdv-rpm-summary-0.9.4-1mdv2010.1
mplayerplugin-3.55-5mdv2010.0
openldap2.3-2.3.43-1mdv2009.0
pidgin-guifications-2.16-7mdv2010.0
policykit-gnome-0.9.2-5mdv2010.1
postgresql8.3-8.3.11-3mdv2010.1
python-numeric-24.2-6mdv2010.0
skype-2.0.0.72-mdv
teg-0.11.2-6mdv2010.0
tightvnc-1.3.10-3mdv2010.1
x11-font-adobe-utopia-100dpi-1.0.2-1mdv2010.1
x11-font-adobe-utopia-75dpi-1.0.2-1mdv2010.1
x11-font-adobe-utopia-type1-1.0.2-1mdv2010.1
Comment 3 Sandro CAZZANIGA 2011-06-12 21:17:13 CEST
Is it still VALID?

CC: (none) => cazzaniga.sandro

Comment 4 Manuel Hiebel 2011-08-28 17:15:43 CEST
well, close as an old

Status: NEW => RESOLVED
Resolution: (none) => OLD